Handcrafted since 2004

Personalized gifts & favors
made with love.

Custom favors, sweet treats, baby gifts, hot cocoa favors and gourmet popcorn for life's happiest celebrations.

Shop Favors What We Make
Personalized Gifts Custom Favors Diaper Cakes & Baby Gifts Made with Love Baby & Newborn Favors Gourmet Popcorn Hot Cocoa Favors
About Baby Love

Gifts and favors that
spark joy.

Baby Love Custom Gifts is a small, family-hearted studio founded in 2004 by Nancy. It began with a simple idea: to design unique custom baby shower diaper cakes and personalized favors that spark joy and warmth in every celebration.

Today the shop has grown well beyond baby, with personalized favors, custom gifts, hot cocoa favors and colorful gourmet popcorn for showers, birthdays, weddings, holidays and parties. Every piece is still handcrafted with love and attention to detail.

Made with

Love

Crafting since

2004

Personalized

For you

What we make

A little something for every celebration.

Personalized Favors

Custom favors for baby showers, birthdays, weddings, bridal showers, holidays and parties.

Custom Gifts

Handcrafted, personalized keepsakes such as cake toppers and custom calendars.

Baby & Newborn Gifts

Baby shower centerpieces, diaper cakes, personalized baby gifts and newborn gifts.

Hot Cocoa Favors

Personalized cocoa favors for holidays, parties, showers, weddings, classmates and coworkers.

Gourmet Popcorn

Colorful gourmet popcorn in fun and creative flavors, including seasonal and specialty blends.

Baby Love Gourmet Popcorn
The shop

Shop handmade favors

Ordering more, or something entirely custom? There is no minimum or maximum, just send me a note.

Handmade reindeer hot cocoa favors by Nancy at Baby Love Custom Gifts
Meet the Maker
Behind the brand

Hi, I'm Nancy.

I specialize in charming custom gifts and personalized favors, like my very popular hot cocoa favors, each one handcrafted with love and attention to detail. My commitment is to make sure every product I design adds a special touch to your event.

Nothing here is AI-generated or drop-shipped. Every order is personally created in my smoke-free, pet-free studio, and when you shop with me you are supporting a small business and a real person who truly appreciates your order.

"I'm grateful to be part of your cherished moments, and I look forward to helping you create memories that last a lifetime. As always, with love, Nancy."

Custom orders welcome.

Baby showers, birthdays, weddings, holidays, classrooms or the office. Tell me your colors, names and theme, and I'll handcraft the rest.

Start a Custom Order
Questions & answers

Frequently asked questions.

Everything you might want to know before ordering. Don't see your question? Just ask.

Yes, custom work is my favorite. Send me a note with what you have in mind, including names, dates, colors, theme or inspiration photos, and I will reply with a quote and timeline within 1 to 2 business days.

No minimum and no maximum. Whether you need a single favor or 500 for a big event, I am happy to accommodate your order size.

Hot cocoa favors have no lead time and ship promptly. Larger custom favors, diaper cakes and centerpieces usually take 1 to 3 weeks depending on the season. For showers, weddings and holidays, please order as early as you can.

Orders are shipped according to your event date so treats arrive fresh, by USPS Priority Mail, UPS or FedEx, whichever offers the best rate for your location. You will receive a tracking number once your order is on its way.

Yes, and I recommend it. The reindeer cocoas are very popular and sell out quickly. Pre-orders ship closer to the holidays or by the date you need them.

All edible items in the cocoa favors are gluten-free, and halal/kosher marshmallows are available as an add-on. Everything is prepared in a smoke-free, pet-free home studio.

Because personalized pieces are made specifically for you, returns are not accepted unless there was a personalization error on my end or the order arrived damaged. Send me a photo within 7 days and I will make it right.

Absolutely. Gift tags with your own message are available for 50 cents each, and I can match them to your colors and theme.
Let's chat

Have an idea for a custom gift?

Custom orders are my favorite. Tell me what you are planning, a baby shower, a wedding, a holiday party or a classroom treat, and I will handcraft it for you.

Send a note

Tell me about your gift.